Suzanne L. Marchand – What the History of the Humanities Can, and Cannot, Learn from the History of Science

This lecture poses the question, what can the history of the humanities learn from the history of science? The answer is, quite a lot; we could certainly include a much more developed inspection of humanistic practices and of the many, often previously unacknowledged, people who contributed to them. But the history of science cannot deliver for us a set of parameters which define our subject clearly, and the history of scientific practices may not yield such exciting results when applied to
the humanities. Today, too, the sciences and humanities find themselves
in quite different positions with respect to the need to deconstruct
legitimizing discourses. If those historians may need to constantly
remind the public that geniuses often have feet of clay, the history
of the humanities has, at least at present, a different burden: to show
that many persons in the past have striven to understand the human
condition, often in ways we now find objectionable, but sometimes in
ways that inspired, illuminated, educated, and liberated the minds of
readers, contemporary and future.

SUZANNE L. MARCHAND is Boyd Professor of European Intellectual History at
Louisiana State University, Baton Rouge. Marchand obtained her B.A. from UC
Berkeley in 1984, and her Ph.D. from the University of Chicago in 1992. She served
as assistant and then associate professor at Princeton University before moving
to LSU in 1999. She is the author, most recently, of Porcelain: A History from the
Heart of Europe (Princeton UP, 2020), which was awarded the Ralph Gomory
Prize of the Business History Conference. She has received fellowships from the
ACLS, Wissenschaftskolleg, Berlin, Max Planck Institut für Wissenschaftsge
schichte, and the Guggenheim Foundation, among others. In 2022–23 she will be
working on a book titled Herodotus and the Instabilities of Western Civilization as a
fellow at the American Academy in Berlin and Princeton’s Humanities Center.

PAUL NOLTE is Professor of Modern and Contemporary History at the Freie
Universität Berlin. His research interests in recent years have centered on trans
formations of democracy, on public intellectuals, the historiography in the Federal
Republic as well as transatlantic history. As chair of the program’s Academic
Advisory Committee Professor Nolte advises fellows and regularly heads the
research colloquium.

This lecture is a joint event by the
Berlin Program for Advanced German and European Studies and the Colloquium zur Zeitgeschichte at the Friedrich Meinecke Institute.